Alvin Waterproof Blackout Roller vs Alvin Basic Premium Blackout Roller: Which to Buy?

Quick Verdict by Room

If the window lives in a bathroom, kitchen or laundry, pick the Alvin Waterproof Blackout Cordless Roller at from $41.99/shade. If the window lives in a bedroom, nursery or media room, pick the Alvin Basic Premium Blackout Cordless Roller at from $41.39/shade. That is the entire answer.

Both shades sit on the same Alvin cordless platform, both rate 100% blackout, both cost within sixty cents of each other at base size, and both ship with the same smart motor option. The deciding factor is not blackout performance, it is the room context: humidity tolerance on one side, drape density and color range on the other.

Option A · Waterproof

Alvin Waterproof Blackout Roller

from $41.99/shade

• Waterproof + oil-resistant, mildew-proof body
• 293 gsm heavyweight, 100% blackout
• Designed for bathroom, kitchen, laundry

Configure Waterproof →

Code JULY · 20% off · Free ship $300+

Option B · Basic Premium

Alvin Basic Premium Blackout Roller

from $41.39/shade

• 315 gsm denser body, soft drape feel
• 100% shading, room-darkening privacy
• Designed for bedroom, nursery, media room

Configure Basic Premium →

Code JULY · 20% off · Free ship $300+

The rest of this piece unpacks the three room scenarios where the answer is clear, plus the one scenario where neither Alvin is the right pick.

Spec Sheet Side by Side

Both Alvin Blackout Rollers run 100% polyester, no blend math to parse, which is the cleanest scenario for the buyer (and a useful contrast with how Two Pages labels its blends on the drapery side). The polyester body is documented as eligible for the OEKO-TEX Standard 100 ecosystem typical of Two Pages roller lines. For the broader picture on roller shade construction, blackout ratings and motorized options across the catalog, the complete roller shades guide sits one layer up from this VS.

Five things to keep in mind from the table. One, the gsm gap is 22 grams, small on paper, real in hand. Two, both rate 100% on the light side. Three, only the Waterproof carries the moisture treatment that lets it survive a bathroom or kitchen window. Four, the Basic Premium adds seven extra colorways compared with the Waterproof. Five, the base price gap is sixty cents, basically a rounding error: do not let pricing drive this decision, let the room drive it.

Real customer installs

Real rooms photographed by verified Two Pages buyers

Verified

6 verified customer photosSourced from verified reviews on Judge.me

With the spec landscape clear, the next three sections walk through the three room verdicts.

When the Waterproof Wins

Three rooms put a polyester roller through hell: the bathroom (sustained 80%+ humidity, twice-daily steam), the kitchen (cooking grease aerosol, water splash near the sink window), and the laundry or basement (dryer exhaust, ambient moisture, ironing steam). In any of these, a standard blackout polyester wicks moisture into the weave, slows its dry time, and grows a faint mildew line along the bottom hem by month six.

The Waterproof body solves all three failure modes at once. The Two Pages spec sheet documents the body as waterproof, oil-resistant and mildew-proof. Functionally that means three things: water beads instead of soaking, kitchen grease wipes off with a damp cloth instead of staining, and the bottom hem stays clean even in a windowless bath that runs hot showers twice a day. The trade is a hand that reads a touch crisper, less cushiony than the Basic Premium, but for a room where the shade gets wiped down weekly, crisp is the right answer.

The cost: the M112 color range is narrower, ten shades of utility palette (Snow, Ivory Beige, Ash, Light Blue, Light Green, Rock, Dark Ash, Jet Black, Rose, Coffee). No deep saturated colors, no fun nursery brights. That tradeoff is fine because nobody installs a roller shade in a powder room for the aesthetic, they install it because the window has to function in a wet environment for a decade.

Bathroom, kitchen or laundry window?

The Waterproof body resists mold, mildew and oil splatter from cooking steam and shower humidity. The 293 gsm hand stays flat through repeated wipe-downs.

Build Your Waterproof →

Code JULY · Made-to-order final sale

When the Basic Premium Wins

The bedroom is where the 22 gsm density edge earns its keep. A roller shade in a bedroom is not just light control, it is the morning experience: how cleanly the bottom hem damps daylight leak around the cassette edge, how quiet the spring sounds at 6am, how the fabric reads in the room when the shade is half-rolled. The Basic Premium hand is documented by Two Pages as a denser, softer feel, and that translates into a tighter edge fit when the cassette is mounted inside the casing.

Two more rooms slot in. The nursery: cordless by design means no loop, no chain, no Window Covering Safety Council failure mode, and the M111 color range opens up the soft kid palette (Sky, Pink, Apple Green, Loquat, Lemon) that the Waterproof line skips. The media room: a denser body kills the daylight reflection bouncing off a flat screen, and the Night and Steel colorways pair cleanly with projector setups that need a dark wall behind them.

Color range is the underrated lever in this comparison. The Basic Premium ships in 17+ shades versus the Waterproof’s ten. For a kid room or a guest bedroom, the extra colorways change what is possible: a Sky blue for a beach-themed nursery, a Loquat or Apple Green for a sunlit play space, a Burgundy Red for a richer adult bedroom. The Waterproof simply does not offer those finishes because nobody is doing creative color in a powder room.

Bedroom, nursery or media room?

The Basic Premium runs 22 gsm denser, with a softer hand and a quieter drape. The color range is the widest in the Alvin line at 17+ shades.

Build Your Basic Premium →

Code JULY · Made-to-order final sale

When Neither: The Honest Skip Cases

Three situations where the answer is not Alvin Waterproof and not Alvin Basic Premium. First: you actually want light filtering, not blackout. Both Alvin SKUs cap at 100% light blockage, which means zero ambient daylight through the shade. If the room needs a soft daytime glow (a sunroom, a reading nook, a north-facing dining room), look at the Alvin Basic Room Darkening Cordless at 191 gsm: same platform, lighter weave, partial light pass-through.

Second: you want a linen look, not a smooth polyester finish. A roller shade in a refined living room reads better with a visible fiber texture, which is what the Alvin Linen Blend Cordless delivers (linen-feel polyester blend, same cordless platform). Third: your window is wider than 71 inches, which is at the upper end of standard Alvin sizing. For an extra-wide living room or master bedroom window, the Atlanta Room Divider Blackout drape system handles the span better than any single roller. The cordless platform on both Alvin SKUs is child-safe per Window Covering Safety Council guidance, but neither was engineered for an 80-inch span.

If any of those three scenarios match your window, route to a different product family and come back to this VS only if the room context shifts.

Pricing & Promo Compared

The base price gap between the two is sixty cents per shade at standard size. The Waterproof opens at from $41.99/shade, the Basic Premium at from $41.39/shade. The motorized variant on both adds $30 to $40/shade for the smart motor configuration, identical premium on both SKUs. A custom drop beyond 72 inches adds 15 to 25% on either, depending on width. The base price floor is not where the decision lives.

Two promo codes to track. The default is JULY, 20% off sitewide, applies to both SKUs at the moment of writing. The Waterproof carries an additional clearance flag, CLEAR35, that runs intermittent 35% off windows when Two Pages clears the M112 line. Always check the product page for the active code at checkout. The free shipping threshold at $300+ is easy to clear if you are configuring two or three shades for a full bathroom plus laundry, or a nursery plus bedroom plus media setup.

FAQ

Are both Alvin shades actually 100% blackout?

Yes. The Waterproof body is rated 100% blackout and the Basic Premium is rated 100% shading, which Two Pages uses as a synonym for total light blockage. Both stop direct sun and UV. The functional difference is not blackout performance, it is the body construction: the Waterproof adds a moisture-resistant treatment for humid rooms, the Basic Premium runs 22 gsm denser for a softer drape in dry rooms.

Can I use the Basic Premium in a bathroom if I’m careful?

Not recommended. The Basic Premium body is standard polyester without the waterproof and mildew-resistant treatment that the Waterproof carries. In a bathroom hitting 80% humidity daily, the Basic Premium fabric absorbs steam, slows its dry time, and grows mildew along the bottom hem at month four to six. The shading rate stays at 100%, but the fabric ages out. For any room near a shower, tub, sink or dryer vent, the Waterproof is the only Alvin pick.

Why is the Waterproof a bit lighter (293 gsm) than the Basic Premium (315 gsm)?

Because the waterproof treatment adds resin and the Two Pages engineering team kept the total hand under 300 gsm so the cordless spring tension still lifts cleanly. The Basic Premium drops the waterproof layer and uses the spec budget on a denser body, which reads as a softer drape. Different priorities, same blackout outcome. Below 290 gsm, the cordless mechanism feels lazy on the lift; above 320 gsm, the spring fights.

Do both Alvin shades come motorized?

Yes. Both ship as cordless manual by default, and both offer a motorized variant for an extra $30 to $40 per shade. The motor pairs with Apple Home, Google Home, Alexa and SmartThings. The note from Two Pages: orders after May 22 ship with the smart motor configuration; orders before that date carry the standard remote-only motor. The smart motor is the right call for any new build.

Which one has the wider color range?

The Basic Premium (M111 line) carries 17+ shades, including kid-friendly Sky, Pink, Apple Green and Loquat, plus three deep darks (Night, Brown, Burgundy Red). The Waterproof (M112 line) carries 10 shades, all neutral utility-room palette: Snow, Ivory Beige, Ash, Light Blue, Light Green, Rock, Dark Ash, Jet Black, Rose, Coffee. For a nursery or a colorful bedroom, Basic Premium is the only option.

What promo code applies to both Alvin Blackout Rollers?

Code JULY runs 20% off sitewide at Two Pages and stacks on both Alvin SKUs at the moment of writing. The Waterproof carries an additional clearance window flag, CLEAR35 (35% off), that is intermittent in the catalog. Two Pages also runs free shipping over $300. Both are made-to-order final sale, so order one swatch set first and confirm width plus drop before configuring.

Final Verdict

Match the shade to the room, not the room to the shade. The Alvin Waterproof Blackout Roller is the right pick for any window that lives in humidity, splash or grease (bathroom, kitchen, laundry, basement), where the mildew-proof body buys a decade of clean operation that the Basic Premium would lose at month six. The Alvin Basic Premium Blackout Roller is the right pick for any window in a dry, comfort-driven room (bedroom, nursery, media), where the 22 gsm density edge and the 17+ color range turn the shade from utility into design. Both rate 100% blackout, both ride the same cordless platform, both ship in 2-3 weeks. The sixty-cent base price gap is not a tiebreaker; the room is the tiebreaker.

Final Decision

If the shade lives in a bathroom, kitchen or laundry, the Waterproof at from $41.99/shade is the only call: it resists mildew, oil and steam where the Basic Premium would warp at month six. For a bedroom, nursery or media room, the denser Basic Premium at from $41.39/shade is the better drape, the wider color range and the quieter daily feel.

Alvin Waterproof Blackout Roller

from $41.99/shade

Configure Waterproof →

Alvin Basic Premium Blackout Roller

from $41.39/shade

Configure Basic Premium →

Code JULY for 20% off either shade · Free shipping over $300 · Made-to-order (final sale)